Klaviyo VS Constant Contact: Which Email Marketing Software Is Better?

In the dynamic world of digital marketing, email marketing remains a cornerstone, offering unmatched direct access to your audience. With the right tools, businesses can craft personalized messages, automate engaging campaigns, and drive significant returns on investment. Choosing the best email marketing software, therefore, is not just a technical decision but a strategic one.

Among the plethora of options available, Klaviyo and Constant Contact stand out as two of the leading platforms. Klaviyo, known for its deep integration capabilities and advanced automation features, caters predominantly to e-commerce businesses looking to scale their operations. On the other hand, Constant Contact offers a user-friendly interface and extensive support, making it ideal for small businesses and newcomers to the digital marketing scene.

This comparison aims to dissect the features, usability, and pricing of Klaviyo and Constant Contact to assist you in making an informed decision. Whether you’re launching a new product line, aiming to increase customer engagement, or seeking to maximize your marketing efforts, understanding how these tools align with your business objectives is crucial. Let’s delve into what each platform has to offer and identify which might be the better choice for your specific needs.

Overview of Klaviyo

Klaviyo is a robust email marketing platform that has rapidly made its mark since its inception in 2012. Based in Boston, it has grown to serve over 50,000 businesses globally, primarily focusing on e-commerce. Klaviyo’s rise is attributed to its powerful automation capabilities and its ability to provide deep integrations with e-commerce platforms like Shopify, WooCommerce, and BigCommerce.

Key Features and Unique Selling Propositions:

• Advanced Segmentation: Klaviyo allows users to segment their audience based on a wide range of behaviors and properties, such as purchasing history and browsing behavior. This enables highly targeted and personalized email campaigns.
• Automation: With Klaviyo, businesses can automate their entire customer journey. From welcome emails to abandoned cart reminders and post-purchase follow-ups, Klaviyo’s automation workflows are designed to increase engagement and sales without additional manpower.
• Real-Time Analytics: Klaviyo offers real-time data tracking, which allows marketers to see the immediate impact of their campaigns and make data-driven decisions quickly.
• Integration Ecosystem: Klaviyo’s strength lies in its seamless integration with numerous e-commerce tools, enhancing its utility by syncing with other platforms used by online stores.

Types of Businesses That Benefit Most from Klaviyo:

• E-commerce Stores: Klaviyo’s features are tailored for online shops of all sizes, particularly those looking to scale. Its integrations with e-commerce platforms make it a valuable tool for businesses focused on online sales.
• D2C Brands: Direct-to-consumer brands find Klaviyo beneficial for its ability to manage direct customer relationships effectively through personalized, automated marketing sequences.
• Subscription-Based Services: Companies that operate on a subscription model benefit from Klaviyo’s ability to manage recurring communications and engage users at each renewal cycle.

In essence, Klaviyo is a powerful ally for any business that relies heavily on e-commerce and desires to harness detailed customer data to enhance its marketing efforts dynamically.

Explore 11 Best Klaviyo Alternatives in 2024

Overview of Constant Contact

Constant Contact has been a prominent player in the email marketing landscape since 1995, making it one of the most established and reliable services in the industry. With a strong focus on small businesses and non-profits, Constant Contact has carved out a significant niche by providing easy-to-use tools and excellent customer support, helping users to execute effective marketing campaigns with minimal technical expertise.

Key Features and Unique Selling Propositions:

• User-Friendly Interface: Constant Contact is renowned for its straightforward and intuitive user interface, which makes it easy for newcomers to navigate and use effectively without a steep learning curve.
• Comprehensive Template Library: The platform offers a vast array of customizable templates that cater to various industries and marketing needs, making it simple for users to create professional-looking emails quickly.
• Event Management Tools: Unique to Constant Contact are its event management features, which include the ability to create event registration forms, manage attendees, and send follow-up communications, providing a holistic approach to event marketing.
• Social Media Integration: The platform extends its functionality to social media, allowing users to manage social advertising and posting directly from their Constant Contact dashboard.

Ideal User Demographic for Constant Contact:

• Small Businesses: With its ease of use and extensive support resources, Constant Contact is particularly well-suited to small businesses that may not have dedicated marketing teams but need to reach their customer base effectively.
• Non-Profits: Non-profit organizations benefit from Constant Contact’s capabilities in managing events and fundraisers, along with its affordable pricing structure.
• Service Providers: Professionals such as realtors, consultants, and local service providers can leverage Constant Contact to maintain communication with clients and promote services through targeted email campaigns.

Overall, Constant Contact offers a solid, user-friendly platform that is especially beneficial for those new to email marketing or those operating with limited resources but who still wish to engage actively with their audiences.

Ease of Use:

When choosing an email marketing platform, ease of use is a critical factor, especially for those with limited technical expertise or resources. Both Klaviyo and Constant Contact have developed their platforms with user-friendliness in mind, but they cater to slightly different user needs.

Comparison of User Interfaces:

• Klaviyo: Klaviyo’s interface is clean and modern, with a dashboard that prioritizes data analytics, showing key metrics at a glance. The platform is designed with advanced users in mind, offering detailed customization options in its campaign and automation builders. This might require a slight learning curve for new users but offers robust tools for those who are familiar with email marketing.
• Constant Contact: Constant Contact’s interface is exceptionally user-friendly, with a more straightforward, intuitive design that makes it easy for beginners to navigate. The platform uses a more guided approach in setting up campaigns, with less jargon and more direct, clear instructions, making it ideal for novices.

Setup Process for Each Platform:

• Klaviyo: Setting up Klaviyo involves a few more steps, particularly when integrating with e-commerce platforms. Users need to connect their online store and import customer data, a process that Klaviyo guides through but can seem complex for a first-timer. However, the integration depth justifies the initial setup complexity.
• Constant Contact: The setup process for Constant Contact is streamlined and straightforward. New users can quickly start creating campaigns after a basic setup that includes setting up an account, adding contacts, and choosing a template. The platform also offers numerous prompts and tutorials to help new users get up to speed.

Availability and Quality of Customer Support and Learning Resources:

• Klaviyo: Klaviyo offers a comprehensive knowledge base, webinars, and a community forum where users can seek advice and share insights. While their customer support is reliable, it may be more geared towards users with a basic understanding of email marketing principles.
• Constant Contact: Constant Contact excels in customer support, providing live chat, email, and phone support with shorter wait times and helpful agents. They also offer a wealth of learning resources, including tutorials, live classes, and webinars designed to help users maximize their use of the platform.

In conclusion, while Klaviyo offers more advanced features that require a bit of a learning curve, Constant Contact focuses on simplicity and support, making it a more accessible choice for beginners or small businesses looking for an effective, straightforward solution.

Email Design and Customization Capabilities

The ability to create visually appealing and engaging emails is essential for successful email marketing. Both Klaviyo and Constant Contact offer a range of tools and options for designing emails, but they cater to different levels of design expertise and needs.

Tools and Flexibility in Email Design:

• Klaviyo: Klaviyo provides a powerful email editor that supports highly customized and dynamic content. Users can drag and drop elements to create custom layouts, and advanced users can even modify HTML directly for further customization. Klaviyo’s strength lies in its ability to create personalized content using customer data, which can dynamically change based on user behavior or segmentation rules.
• Constant Contact: Constant Contact’s email editor is more focused on simplicity and ease of use. While it offers less flexibility than Klaviyo in terms of raw customization, it provides a wide range of easy-to-use templates that can be quickly adapted with simple drag-and-drop tools. This makes it ideal for users who need to create professional-looking emails without requiring deep technical knowledge.

Availability of Templates and Customization Options:

• Klaviyo: Klaviyo offers a variety of templates, but its focus is more on the customization of each template to fit the specific needs of a campaign or audience segment. The platform is designed to leverage user data for personalization beyond just using the recipient’s name, incorporating browsing behavior, purchase history, and other custom attributes into the email design.
• Constant Contact: Constant Contact shines in this area with an extensive library of templates that cater to a wide range of industries and occasions. Each template is fully customizable within the limits of the editor, and users can easily add their own images, text, and brand colors without needing to know any HTML.

Comparison of the Visual Email Builder Tools:

• Klaviyo: Klaviyo’s visual email builder is robust, offering detailed control over every aspect of an email’s design. It includes features like A/B testing of different email designs directly within the builder and the ability to use conditional blocks for content personalization.
• Constant Contact: The visual builder in Constant Contact is designed for speed and ease of use. It may not offer as much control as Klaviyo’s builder, but it compensates by being extremely user-friendly, making it quick and easy to assemble an email with a professional appearance.

In summary, Klaviyo offers more sophisticated tools for those who want to delve deeply into personalized and highly customized email designs, making it ideal for marketers who are comfortable with data-driven customization. On the other hand, Constant Contact provides an excellent solution for those who prefer simplicity and speed, offering a broad selection of templates and an easy-to-use editor that requires minimal technical skills.

Automation and Workflow Features

Automation is a critical component of effective email marketing, allowing businesses to deliver timely and relevant content to their audience with minimal ongoing effort. Klaviyo and Constant Contact both offer automation features, but they cater to different complexities and types of workflows.

Comparison of Automation Features:

• Klaviyo: Klaviyo’s automation capabilities are highly advanced and are particularly suited to e-commerce businesses that require detailed, behavior-based triggers. Klaviyo allows for the creation of complex automation sequences that can be triggered by specific customer actions like visiting a product page, abandoning a cart, or making a purchase. These automations can include multiple branches based on further actions or lack of actions, providing highly personalized customer journeys.
• Constant Contact: Constant Contact offers more straightforward automation features, which are easier to set up and manage. It includes basic autoresponders for welcoming new subscribers, birthday emails, and other date-based triggers. While not as intricate as Klaviyo’s, these features are sufficient for businesses that need standard follow-up emails and basic customer engagement without complex setup.

Examples of Workflow Capabilities in Both Tools:

• Klaviyo: For instance, Klaviyo allows you to create a workflow that sends a welcome email series to new subscribers, follows up with a discount offer if they haven’t purchased within a week, and sends targeted product recommendations based on their browsing history.
• Constant Contact: In contrast, Constant Contact might be used to set up a simple workflow where all new subscribers receive a welcome email, a follow-up email a few days later, and then regular monthly newsletters. It’s more about maintaining contact and less about personalized customer journeys based on detailed behaviors.

How Each Platform Handles Segmentation and Triggers:

• Klaviyo: Segmentation in Klaviyo is highly detailed, allowing users to segment their audiences based on nearly any data collected, including custom attributes. Triggers for automations can be finely tuned to match specific behaviors, ensuring that the communications sent are highly relevant and timely.
• Constant Contact: Segmentation in Constant Contact is more basic, focusing on demographic information and simple behaviors such as email opens and click-throughs. Triggers are generally limited to more straightforward scenarios like joining a list or specific dates.

In conclusion, Klaviyo is the superior choice for businesses that need sophisticated, data-driven automation capabilities to deliver highly personalized email campaigns. Constant Contact, on the other hand, is ideal for small businesses or those just starting with email marketing who need easy-to-implement automation that keeps their audience engaged without the need for complex setup. Both platforms provide valuable tools, but the best choice depends significantly on the specific needs and sophistication of the email marketing strategies envisaged by the business.

Integration with Other Tools

Integrating email marketing software with other business tools and customer relationship management (CRM) systems can greatly enhance efficiency and streamline marketing efforts. Both Klaviyo and Constant Contact offer a range of integration options, though their focuses and strengths differ.

Overview of Integration Capabilities with Other Marketing Tools and CRMs:

• Klaviyo: Klaviyo is highly regarded for its deep integration capabilities, particularly with e-commerce platforms. It seamlessly connects with major e-commerce systems such as Shopify, Magento, and BigCommerce. Beyond e-commerce, Klaviyo also integrates with CRMs like Salesforce, enabling detailed data synchronization and enhanced customer insights.
• Constant Contact: While Constant Contact may not offer as deep integrations as Klaviyo, it supports a wide range of integrations with popular tools that small businesses commonly use. This includes CRMs like Salesforce and Zoho, social media platforms, and tools like WordPress and Shopify, which helps in creating a cohesive marketing strategy across channels.

Specific Popular Integrations that Add Value to Each Platform:

• Klaviyo:
  • Shopify: One of Klaviyo’s standout integrations is with Shopify. This integration allows for the automatic syncing of customer data and purchase behavior, enabling highly targeted and personalized marketing campaigns.
  • Facebook Ads: Klaviyo integrates with Facebook Ads to allow users to create custom audiences based on their email lists and directly target or retarget customers via social media campaigns.
  • Zapier: Through Zapier, Klaviyo can connect with over a thousand other web services, expanding its functionality and automation capabilities across various tools that may not have a direct integration.
• Constant Contact:
  • Shopify: Constant Contact also integrates with Shopify, though with a focus on simplifying email campaign creation based on purchase data rather than the extensive automation offered by Klaviyo.
  • Eventbrite: For businesses that hold events, Constant Contact’s integration with Eventbrite simplifies managing invitations, registrations, and follow-ups directly from the email platform.
  • Social Media Platforms: Constant Contact offers integrations with social media tools, allowing users to manage social posts and track the effectiveness of social media campaigns alongside email efforts.

In conclusion, Klaviyo’s integrations are geared towards high-volume, data-driven e-commerce businesses that require sophisticated automation and targeting capabilities. In contrast, Constant Contact provides broad integration options that support a more generalist approach, suitable for small businesses needing to connect various basic tools to enhance their marketing efforts. The choice between these platforms should be guided by the specific needs of the business, particularly in terms of the depth and breadth of integrations required.

Reporting and Analytics

Effective email marketing is driven by data. Understanding how campaigns perform is crucial to refining strategies and improving engagement over time. Klaviyo and Constant Contact both offer comprehensive reporting and analytics tools, but they differ in depth and detail, catering to different levels of user needs.

Analysis of the Reporting Features of Both Platforms:

• Klaviyo: Klaviyo offers highly detailed analytics that are particularly useful for e-commerce businesses looking to track customer behavior and campaign effectiveness minutely. It provides real-time data on opens, clicks, and conversions, but goes further by integrating this data with customer purchase history and browsing behavior to create detailed reports on customer lifetime value, churn rate, and segmentation effectiveness. Klaviyo’s dashboard can be customized to display key metrics that matter most to the user, providing a powerful tool for data-driven decision-making.
• Constant Contact: Constant Contact provides a more streamlined analytics experience that is easy to understand and navigate, making it ideal for small businesses or those new to email marketing. Its reports include essential metrics such as open rates, click rates, and the number of unsubscribes, with data presented in clear, graphical formats. Constant Contact also offers comparisons to industry averages, which helps users understand how their campaigns stack up against similar businesses.

How Data is Presented and What Insights Users Can Gain:

• Klaviyo: Data in Klaviyo is presented in various customizable graphs and charts, allowing users to dive deep into the analytics. Users can track the performance of not just entire campaigns but also individual emails and customer segments. Insights from Klaviyo enable businesses to fine-tune their marketing strategies, optimize send times, and even predict future trends based on customer behavior patterns.
• Constant Contact: Constant Contact’s data presentation is straightforward, focusing on delivering information in an accessible format. The platform provides visual insights through pie charts, bar graphs, and line charts, making it easy to assess the overall success of campaigns quickly. While it may lack the depth of Klaviyo, the insights provided are pertinent for businesses to make informed decisions on basic email marketing strategies.

Comparative Effectiveness in Measuring Campaign Performance:

• Klaviyo: Klaviyo excels in its ability to provide actionable insights based on comprehensive data analysis. It is particularly effective in environments where the integration of detailed customer data can lead to highly optimized marketing strategies. The effectiveness of Klaviyo’s analytics is seen in its ability to increase ROI through targeted, behavior-based marketing.
• Constant Contact: While Constant Contact may not offer the same level of detail in its analytics, it is very effective for users who need straightforward insights into campaign performance without the complexity. It helps in understanding basic campaign effectiveness and making quick adjustments based on clear, concise data.

In summary, Klaviyo is ideal for businesses that need detailed, data-driven insights to continually refine complex marketing strategies, particularly in e-commerce. In contrast, Constant Contact is best suited for smaller businesses or those at an earlier stage of email marketing maturity, providing all necessary metrics to track and improve their email marketing efforts effectively.

Pricing and Plans

Understanding the pricing structures of Klaviyo and Constant Contact is crucial for businesses to choose the platform that best fits their budget and marketing needs. Both platforms offer different pricing tiers based on the features and scale of use, with specific considerations for businesses of varying sizes.

Breakdown of Pricing Structures:

• Klaviyo: Klaviyo’s pricing is primarily based on the number of contacts in your email list, with rates increasing as the list grows. This allows businesses to start small and scale up as their needs expand. The platform offers a free tier for up to 250 contacts and 500 email sends, which is a great way to test out its capabilities. Beyond this, pricing starts at approximately $20 per month for up to 500 contacts, with the cost increasing as more contacts are added. For larger businesses, Klaviyo also offers enterprise-level solutions with custom pricing to accommodate advanced needs like more sophisticated segmentation and personalization features.
• Constant Contact: Constant Contact offers two main plans: Email and Email Plus, with pricing based on the number of contacts. The Email plan starts at around $20 per month for up to 500 contacts, which includes basic features like email marketing, customizable templates, and reporting. The Email Plus plan starts at approximately $45 per month and includes more advanced features such as automated email series, online donations, and event marketing capabilities. Like Klaviyo, the prices increase with the number of contacts.

Comparison of What Each Plan Offers and Suitability for Different Business Sizes:

• Klaviyo: Ideal for medium to large e-commerce businesses that require detailed analytics and sophisticated automation to drive sales. The scaling pricing model suits growing businesses well, as they can start with a smaller, less expensive plan and move to a more comprehensive plan as their needs evolve.
• Constant Contact: Best suited for small to medium-sized businesses or non-profits that need reliable email marketing tools without complex setup. The jump from the Email to the Email Plus plan provides access to features that support more engaging and interactive content, which can be beneficial as a business grows.

Any Hidden Costs or Value-Added Services:

• Klaviyo: While Klaviyo’s base plans cover most features, high-volume senders might encounter higher costs than expected as their list grows. Additionally, accessing more advanced technical support can come at an additional cost.
• Constant Contact: One of the key value-added services of Constant Contact is their extensive customer support, included in the subscription without additional costs. However, users should be aware of potential fees for add-ons like additional users or specialized services not covered under the basic plans.

In conclusion, Klaviyo and Constant Contact cater to different types of users with their pricing structures. Klaviyo is more suitable for businesses that focus on leveraging customer data to maximize email marketing ROI, while Constant Contact provides an affordable and straightforward solution for businesses needing basic to moderate email marketing capabilities without the complexity of advanced automation.

Pros and Cons:

When deciding between Klaviyo and Constant Contact for email marketing solutions, it’s crucial to understand the strengths and weaknesses of each platform. This knowledge will guide businesses in selecting the tool that best aligns with their specific needs.

Klaviyo:

Pros:

• Advanced Automation and Segmentation: Allows for highly personalized email campaigns based on detailed customer data and behaviors.
• Deep E-commerce Integration: Particularly with platforms like Shopify, making it ideal for e-commerce businesses focused on maximizing customer engagement and revenue.
• Robust Analytics: Provides detailed insights that help businesses make data-driven decisions to optimize their marketing strategies.

Cons:

• Complexity: May be overwhelming for beginners or small businesses without a dedicated marketing team.
• Cost: Can become expensive as the email list grows, which might be a consideration for businesses with a tight budget.
• Learning Curve: Requires some time to fully understand and utilize all the features effectively.

Recommended Use-Cases: Klaviyo is best suited for medium to large e-commerce businesses that require detailed insights into customer behavior and the ability to automate complex marketing sequences based on those insights.

Constant Contact:

Pros:

• User-Friendly Interface: Easy for beginners and non-technical users to navigate and use effectively.
• Wide Range of Templates: Offers numerous customizable email templates suitable for various industries and occasions.
• Strong Support and Resources: Provides extensive customer support and educational resources that are beneficial for small businesses.

Cons:

• Limited Automation Features: While sufficient for basic needs, it lacks the depth of automation and segmentation capabilities found in Klaviyo.
• Less Tailored for E-commerce: Does not offer as deep integrations with e-commerce platforms or the advanced features that are specifically beneficial for online stores.

Recommended Use-Cases: Constant Contact is ideal for small businesses, non-profits, and those just starting with email marketing who need a straightforward tool that is easy to manage and provides effective basic marketing capabilities.

Final Thoughts on Choosing the Best Platform Based on Specific Criteria: Choosing between Klaviyo and Constant Contact should be based on specific business needs:

• Size and Nature of Business: Klaviyo is preferable for larger e-commerce businesses looking for growth through sophisticated marketing techniques. Constant Contact is more suited for smaller businesses or those with simpler email marketing needs.
• Technical Capability: Businesses with a capable marketing team that can handle complex tools might prefer Klaviyo, while those without should consider the ease of use offered by Constant Contact.
• Budget: Consider the long-term costs associated with each platform, especially as the business scales and the email list grows.

Ultimately, the decision should align with the business’s marketing goals, technical capabilities, and budget. Each platform offers distinct advantages, and the choice should support the overarching strategy of the business’s email marketing efforts.

Conclusion

In this comparison of Klaviyo and Constant Contact, we’ve explored various facets of both email marketing platforms—from ease of use and design capabilities to automation features and integration options. Klaviyo stands out with its advanced analytics and detailed automation suited for e-commerce businesses that thrive on data-driven strategies. In contrast, Constant Contact offers a more user-friendly interface with strong support and educational resources, making it ideal for small businesses and beginners in email marketing.

When choosing the right platform, consider the size of your business, the complexity of your marketing needs, and your team’s technical proficiency. Each platform has its strengths and is designed to meet different marketing demands. Reflect on your specific business goals and resources to ensure that your choice not only fits your current needs but also aligns with your future growth and marketing strategies.